Jeff Ulbrich desperately needed some help.
The Bills had taken it to the Jets, gashed them in the ground while Josh Allen seemingly toyed with Ulbrich’s defense, and thought they would be carrying a 20-10 halftime lead into the locker room.
They thought wrong.
Aaron Rodgers, first-and-10 at his 48, with all night to throw because the Bills rushed only two, launched the Hail Ulbrich from his 43. Time expired while the ball was in the air.
Allen Lazard leaped for the ball and the three Bills who surrounded him leaped with him.
Lazard came down with it.
It was Rodgers’ fourth Hail Mary TD. No other player in the NFL has more than two touchdowns on Hail Marys since 2008.
It made Ulbrich, a 23-20 loser, look like a genius for calling a pair of timeouts at a time when a trash-talking Allen was engineering a drive that concluded with an 11-yard TD pass to Dawson Knox with 21 seconds left before intermission.
Alas, it takes more than Aaron Rodgers completing a Hail Ulbrich to beat Josh Allen.
You can blame Rodgers for not getting his team in the end zone after having first-and-goal at the 3, and you can blame him for not winning it when Ulbrich needed him to win it in the fourth quarter.
Rodgers threw for a season-high 294 yards. This one isn’t on him.
The real blame belongs to Ulbrich’s coveted defense and FG kicker Greg Zuerlein, who sabotaged the Jets with a pair of missed FGs off the left upright and prevented them from a share of first place.
And 11 penalties that had Jets fans muttering to themselves:
Same Old Saleh Jets.
And Aaron Rodgers isn’t Josh Allen and the Jets aren’t the Bills.
“We’re fortunate we have the best Hail Mary thrower in the history of this game,” Ulbrich said. “He made somebody pay again. You catch those waves of momentum, you gotta ride it, and you gotta finish a team, which we didn’t do.”
Rodgers has always prided himself on being a finisher.
Ulbrich would be forced to ask Rodgers, starting at his 30, for one last finish trailing 23-20 with 3:43 and three timeouts remaining.
He tried what amounted to a third-and-16 Hail Ulbrich, following a Joe Tippmann holding penalty, and Mike Williams slipped and Taron Johnson intercepted with 1:52 left.
“I’m here to win those games,” Rodgers said, “but we gotta be on our details.”
Get the insider’s view on Gang Green
Sign up for Inside the Jets by Brian Costello, a weekly Sports+ exclusive.
Thank you
Rodgers was brought here to beat Allen and the Bills on a Monday night at MetLife Stadium with a share of first place on the line, no matter who, Robert Saleh or Jeff Ulbrich, was standing on the sideline as his head coach. He was brought here to end the Bills’ four-year stranglehold on the AFC East, whether Nathaniel Hackett or Todd Downing was the play-caller.
He could not rise above the rubble around him.
Maybe only MVP Aaron could have found a way.
Ulbrich’s defense, gashed by the run in the first half, was energized when the second half began.
A roughing-the-passer penalty on A.J. Epenesa had enabled Breece Hall on third-and-2 to rip off a 42-yard explosive down the left sideline to the Buffalo 3 midway through the third quarter.
MetLife Stadium: “BREEEEECE.”
But Rodgers couldn’t get it in. Ulbrich settled for the chippie FG. Jets 20, Bills 20.
It was still Jets 20, Bills 20 because a Tyron Smith holding call nullified a 4-yard Braelon Allen TD run before Taylor Rapp violently dislodged a would-be 12-yard TD pass to Garrett Wilson and Zuerlein missed a 32-yard FG.
“Should been a 30-plus point game on offense,” Rodgers said.
There was a 42-yard pass interference on Quincy Williams and a 23-yard PI on D.J. Reed. There was a declined 12-men-on-the-field penalty because of a Tony Adams PI.
The offensive line had sagged late in the second quarter. Dorian Williams sacked Rodgers on first down, Morgan Moses false-started, and Epenesa beat Smith and buried Rodgers for an 8-yard sack. He was sore as usual afterwards.
Downing wisely deployed Hall in the passing game. Hall needed to regain his swagger to keep Rodgers from attempting 54 passes and taking a beating. And so: A 21-yard reception. A 24-yard gain. Later, a 23-yard reception. And that 42-yard romp.
“We are by no means out of this thing,” Ulbrich said.
The Jets are 2-4. And he is 0-1. One Hail Ulbrich won’t be enough.