Key takeaways:

• Cocoa prices have surged, forcing urgent product reformulation.
• Brands are cutting cocoa by up to 15% using clean-label solutions.
• The crisis is accelerating long-term innovation in chocolate.

Cocoa prices have gone through the roof, soaring past $12,000 per metric ton this year. That’s more than six times what they were in 2022.

Blame a perfect storm: relentless crop disease, wild weather and a supply chain under serious pressure. The result is a projected 374,000-ton shortfall for the 2024/25 season, according to the International Cocoa Organization. That’s the fourth year in a row of deficit.

The epicenter of the crisis is West Africa, which supplies around 60% of the world’s cocoa. Farms in Ghana and Côte d’Ivoire have been battered by Cocoa Swollen Shoot Virus Disease, an aggressive plant virus that stunts yields and spreads fast.

Add in erratic weather patterns – floods, droughts, unseasonal rain – and you’ve got the makings of a long term supply disaster. Even processors are starting to stockpile beans, further fuelling speculation and tightening markets.

And while replanting is underway, it could be another 5 to 7 years before those efforts bear real fruit.

For producers – especially in the bakery and snack world where cocoa is central to flavor, color, texture and indulgence – this isn’t just a blip. It’s a full-blown reckoning.

How brands are fighting back

Rather than just shrink portions or swallow costs, many manufacturers are going back to the lab and getting creative with how cocoa is used, where it’s used and how its flavor can be amplified or mimicked.

“In response to rising cocoa costs and supply instability, food and beverage R&D teams are employing a variety of strategies ranging from flavor optimization to process enhancements to maximize the impact of every gram of cocoa used,” said Tom Fuzer, VP of Market Strategy at global ingredient supplier Howtian.

At Howtian’s application lab in Zhucheng, China, trials have shown that cocoa use can be reduced by up to 13% without sacrificing taste. The trick? A mix of longer conching times and clean label flavor modulators that help intensify the natural cocoa notes.

“Extending the conching process by 10% to 15% can really enhance Maillard reactions and deepen the roasted flavor,” Fuzer explained. “It allows you to bring out more complexity, even with less cocoa.”

Producers are also experimenting with microencapsulated cocoa aromas and naturally sweet powders like lucuma and carob, which add top-note richness and help round out reduced-cocoa recipes.

In trials with chocolate protein shakes and powdered drinks, taste testers rated the reduced-cocoa versions nearly as highly as the originals, thanks to the clever use of botanical boosters and texture enhancers.

Not just a quick fix

This isn’t a temporary patch job. The current cocoa squeeze is speeding up the entire R&D process.

“We’ve seen timelines compress dramatically,” said Fuzer. “Some companies are running more pilot tests in parallel and investing in rapid sensory testing, so they can evaluate double the number of prototypes in the same amount of time.”

The upside is quicker decisionmaking; faster reformulations; and more room for long term planning. In many cases, R&D teams are getting ahead of the next crisis by diversifying flavor profiles early on.

“We’re not just looking at how to stretch cocoa – we’re looking at how to move away from depending on it entirely,” Fuzer said. “Blending in complementary flavors like coffee, tea, fruit or spice can reduce cocoa reliance and build resilience into product lines.”

He predicts that within five years, chocolate-style products could routinely contain 10% or more of these kinds of flavor pairings. It’s less about imitation, more about evolution.

Clean labels till rules

Of course, none of this matters if the end product doesn’t taste great or if it doesn’t pass the clean label test.

Consumers have high expectations when it comes to chocolate. According to Howtian’s research, 80% of people say they’ll drop a product if the chocolate flavor isn’t strong enough. But they’re just as quick to reject unfamiliar ingredients – just one suspicious-sounding additive can knock down purchase intent by 10%.

That’s why the current wave of innovation is leaning hard into plant-based flavor systems and multifunctional ingredients that deliver on both taste and transparency.

Also read → How bakery producers can avoid the sting of runaway cocoa prices

Some brands are even exploring plant protein hydrolysates and fat mimetics to help replicate the creamy mouthfeel of cocoa butter, especially in spreads and baked goods where texture is everything.

And while every chocolate-adjacent category is feeling the pressure, some are being hit harder than others. Confectionery is especially vulnerable – products like dark chocolate and truffles often contain 40% cocoa solids or more. Baked goods such as brownies, chocolate muffins and sandwich cookies are also under strain.

Ready-to-drink beverages, on the other hand, may have more wiggle room. These products often contain only 1%-3% cocoa and can rely more heavily on flavor infusions and aroma systems to maintain the sensory experience.

A different kind of chocolate future

The era of cheap, abundant cocoa appears to be over, at least for the foreseeable future. But with that shift comes an opportunity.

This crisis has cracked open a new wave of creativity. From conching tweaks to botanical blends and fast-tracked R&D, the way we think about chocolate is changing – and quickly.

The most agile companies are the ones using this moment not just to patch holes, but to rethink their approach to chocolate from the ground up.

“It’s not just about surviving the cocoa crisis,” said Fuzer. “It’s about reimagining chocolate itself.”

Read More